Connecticut Appellate Court October 12, 2004, AC 23009 (Dent v. Lovejoy)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-10-2004

Opinion

WEST, J.

The plaintiff, Stephen G. Dent, appeals from the judgment of the trial court, rendered after a trial to the court, denying his request for a declaratory judgment, injunctive relief and damages resulting from the presence of a European birch tree within the boundaries of a view easement. On appeal, the plaintiff claims that the court improperly construed the language in his deed as exempting from the view easement those trees and shrubs planted before March 1, 1956. The substitute defendants, Allen P. Lovejoy, Charles F. Lovejoy and Jennifer L. Craddock, cross appeal from that portion of the judgment granting the plaintiffs request for the same relief with respect to a grey birch clump that also exists within the boundaries of the view easement. On cross appeal, they claim that the court improperly (1) concluded that the grey birch clump was subject to the view easement, (2) failed to consider their special

*458

defense that the view easement was terminated by prescription, (3) awarded $8000 in damages to the plaintiff for the interference with his use and enjoyment of the view easement and (4) failed to consider the testimony of the view easement’s grantor as to his intent in granting the easement. We reverse in part the judgment of the trial court.

The following facts are relevant to these appeals. Sometime before 1956, Irven J. Brod acquired approximately fourteen acres of waterfront property in the Riverside section of Greenwich. The property contained a single stone residence, which stood at the crest of a hill, its axis running east to west and its rear facing southward, overlooking Cos Cob Harbor, Hannah Maria Island and Long Island Sound. Also facing southward were an attached terrace and a sunken garden, from which the property sloped downward until it reached the shore of the harbor.

In 1956, Brod subdivided the fourteen acre parcel into nine lots, only one of which was developed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.