District Court, D. Delaware July 16, 2004, CIV.A. 03-469 JJF (MKS Instruments, Inc. v. Advanced Energy Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-07-2004

MEMORANDUM OPINION

FARNAN, District Judge.

Presently before me is the Motion For Partial Summary Judgment Of Non-Infringement Under The Doctrine Of Equivalents (D.I. 139) filed by Advanced Energy Industries, Inc. For the reasons discussed, the Motion will be granted.

BACKGROUND

I. General Background

Advanced Energy Industries, Inc. (“Advanced”) and MKS both manufacture components used in semiconductor processing equipment. MKS alleges that Advanced infringes, both literally and under the doctrine of equivalents, U.S. Patent No. 6,150,628 (“ ’628 patent”), and several continuations or continuation-in-parts of the ’628 patent: U.S. Patent Nos. 6,388,226 (“ ’226 patent”), 6,486,431 (“ ’431 patent”), 6,552,296 (“’296 patent”), and 6,559,408 (“ ’408 patent”). By its instant motion, Advanced seeks summary judgment against MKS’s claims under the doctrine of equivalents.

II. Parties’ Contentions

Advanced contends that MKS has only produced conclusory allegations about the doctrine and has not offered expert testimony or other evidence supporting the doctrine’s application. Advanced contends that this failure to supply expert opinion will prevent MKS from remedying its failure at trial because opinions offered by experts at trial must have been disclosed in an expert report, and the time for filing such reports has lapsed.

MKS contends that it should be allowed to pursue its allegations under the doctrine of equivalents. MKS contends that Advanced plans to defend against infringement by offering semantic argument related to slight differences between the accused device and a literal reading of the claim construction. For example, MKS contends that Advanced will argue that its gas mixing device does not “enhance” the interaction between the feed gas and the plasma as required by the corresponding claim. MKS contends that argument on the doctrine of equivalents is necessary to confront this defense.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.