District Court, M.D. Florida May 19, 2004, 8:01CV943T-23TGW (Public Citizen, Inc. v. Pinellas County)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-05-2004

ORDER

MERRYDAY, District Judge.

Public Citizen, Inc., and Public Citizen Foundation, Inc. (collectively, “Public Citizen”); Greenpeace, Inc., and Greenpeace Fund, Inc. (collectively, “Greenpeace”); American Charities for Reasonable Fund-raising Regulation, Inc. (“American Charities”);

1

and the Direct Marketing Association, Inc. (“DMA”)

2

(collectively, the “charities”), move for summary judgment to enjoin the enforcement of Pinellas County Ordinance No. 93-106 (the “ordinance”), which regulates the solicitation of charitable contributions in Pinellas County

*1279

(Docs. 42 & 43).

3

The charities assert claims pursuant to Section 1983 of Title 42, United States Code (Doc. 1), and contend that the ordinance on its face and as applied to the charities violates the United States Constitution (Doc. 43).

4

Specifically, the charities contend that the ordinance (1) imposes an impermissible prior restraint of protected speech in violation of the First Amendment, (2) imposes an unreasonable burden on protected speech in violation of the First Amendment, and (3) unduly burdens interstate commerce in violation of Article I’s Commerce Clause (Doc. I).

5

The charities contend that the ordinance fails to achieve its stated purpose of preventing deception, fraud, and misrepresentation and of promoting the disclosure of information useful to a potential donor.

Pinellas County and Sheryl Lord, the director of the county’s Department of Justice and Consumer Services

6

(collectively, the “county”), move for summary judgment and argue that the ordinance (1) is narrowly tailored to advance a substantial interest and (2) comports with the Commerce Clause (Doc. 59).

7

In addition, the county contends that an earlier action by fundraising consultants, in which American Charities appeared, adjudicates the charities’ claims and renders this action an impermissible “second bite at the apple” (Doc. 60).

I. BACKGROUND

A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.