District Court, N.D. Ohio March 1, 2004, 3:04 CV 7030 (Taverns for Tots, Inc. v. City of Toledo)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-03-2004

ORDER

CARR, District Judge.

This is § 1983 case arising under the First Amendment to and Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Federal Constitution. The plaintiff, Taverns for Tots, is an Ohio not-for-profit corporation. Plaintiff claims that the defendants City of Toledo, Ohio, and its Mayor, Jack Ford, have violated the plaintiffs constitutional rights by enactment and enforcement of the Toledo’s Clean Indoor Air Act of 2003.

1

Plaintiff initially filed suit in the Lucas County, Ohio, Court of Common Pleas. The defendants removed the case to this court. Thereafter defendants filed a counterclaim, asserting,

inter alia,

that the plaintiff is a sham corporation, created to help area bars and restaurants evade the strictures and enforcement of the anti-smoking ordinance. The City contends that, in view of this purpose, Taverns for Tots is not a bona fide charity, and, as a result, cannot claim the benefit of any exemption in § 1779.04 of the ordinance in favor of not-for-profit corporations.

2

*937

The defendants have filed a motion for preliminary injunctive relief to prevent plaintiff and its associated bars and restaurants from holding “events” at which smoking is permitted in violation of the ordinance. Following issuance of a temporary restraining order in defendants’ favor, a hearing on defendants’ motion for a preliminary injunction was held on February 5, 2004.

3

For the reasons that follow, defendants’ motion for a preliminary injunction will be granted.

BACKGROUND

This case follows an earlier suit,

D.A.B.E. Inc. v. City of Toledo,

292 F.Supp.2d 968 (N.D.Ohio 2003), in which several owners of bars and restaurants in Toledo raised a constitutional challenge to the facial validity of the anti-smoking ordinance. That constitutional challenge, brought under the Constitution’s Takings Clause, was unsuccessful.

Id.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.