District Court, D. Utah February 18, 2004, 2:03-mj-00339 (United States v. Serawop)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-2004

ORDER APPOINTING EXPERT ON POSSIBLE LOST INCOME RESTITUTION

CASSELL, District Judge.

The court has before it two homicide cases in which the same issue regarding possible restitution for lost income has arisen. In

United States v. Serawop,

the defendant was found guilty by a jury of voluntary manslaughter while within Indian Country. The victim in that case was Beyonce Serawop, a three-month-old baby. Defendant Serawop, frustrated by his baby daughter’s crying, “lost it” and threw the child into a sink or toilet, killing her.

1

In

United States v. Bedonie,

the defendant pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter. She was drinking beer while driving a car in a reckless manner. She crashed the car, killing Mr. Brian Johnson, a passenger. Mr. Johnson was a promising young artist who had recently graduated from high school. He provided financial support to his impoverished mother.

Both of these cases present the issue of whether the court should order restitution “for income lost by such victim as a result of such offense” under the Mandatory Victim Restitution Act (MVRA)

2

or, if that statute is inapplicable, the Victim Witness Protection Act.

3

Because the two cases present a parallel legal issue, the court has associated them for purposes of briefing and argument.

To assist the court in calculating lost income in these cases, the court believed it might be desirable to receive the views of an expert in financial loss calculations. The court is authorized to appointed its own expert by both Rule 706 of the Federal Rules of Evidence

4

and by its inherent “general power of calling witnesses in aid of justice.”

5

In addition, the court has power to appoint a “special master” to resolve issues regarding restitution.

6

The court intends to invoke its powers under all these authorities in this order and to rely on the fact that Congress has forbidden any restriction on the kind of information that the court can receive for sentencing purposes.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.