District Court, D. Massachusetts November 5, 2004, MDL NO. 04-1592 (In Re Columbia University Patent Litigation)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-11-2004

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

WOLF, District Judge.

I.

SUMMARY

The Trustees of the Columbia University in the City of New York (“Columbia”)

*37

have moved to dismiss the declaratory-judgment claims in these multidistrict litigation cases. Columbia alleges that its covenant not to sue the plaintiff drug companies on the claims of Patent No. 6,455,-275 (the “ ’275 patent”) as they now read extinguishes the constitutionally required actual cases or controversies between the parties with regard to plaintiffs’ requests for declaratory judgment. Plaintiffs oppose this motion.

For the reasons set forth in this Memorandum, however, Columbia’s contention is correct. The covenant not to sue means that none of the plaintiffs now has the legally required reasonable apprehension that it will face an infringement suit if the court does not declare the ’275 patent invalid and/or unenforceable. Moreover, the court has some discretion as to whether to exercise its jurisdiction even where an actual case or controversy exists. In the circumstances of these cases, even if contrary to the court’s conclusion subject matter jurisdiction now exists, it would be most appropriate to dismiss the requests for declaratory judgment rather than devote a substantial amount of scarce judicial resources to rendering an essentially advisory opinion on hypothetical facts concerning contingencies that are not likely to occur.

Therefore, plaintiffs’ requests for judgment will be dismissed. In addition, the parties are being ordered to: confer; identify for the court the remaining issues in this multidistrict litigation; inform the court whether they request an opportunity to attempt to settle the remaining issues; and, if not, propose a schedule for their judicial resolution.

II.

FACTS

The plaintiffs are drug companies which have licensed from Columbia all patents deriving from an application that Columbia filed in 1980 (the “Axel Patents”).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.