Supreme Court of Oklahoma December 7, 2004, 100,164 (Howell v. Texaco Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-12-2004

TAYLOR, J.

¶ 1 The issues presented for review are: (1) What is the appropriate method for determining market value of gas at the wellhead if the first arm’s-length sale occurs after the gas has been processed; (2) Whether a producer has a fiduciary duty to a royalty owner based solely on a lease and communitization agreement; and (3) Whether there is a genuine issue of material fact that the producer is liable to the plaintiffs for actual and constructive fraud.

I. PROCEDURAL HISTORY

¶2 The-plaintiffs are owners of mineral rights in the Sho-Vel-Tum Field, which is primarily located in Stephens and Carter counties in Oklahoma. The plaintiffs filed suit in Stephens County, Oklahoma, against Texaco Inc., Texaco Exploration and Production Inc. (Texaco), the Humphries Unit (collectively respondents), and three other units alleging that they had breached their lease contracts by underpaying royalties, had breached their fiduciary duties, and had committed fraud. The three other units are not part of the proceedings before this Court.

¶ 3 Texaco submits there were three basic types of leases involved in the proceedings before the trial court: (1) leases which base royalty on the market value or proceeds at the prevailing market rate at the mouth of the well or at the well (market value leases), (2) leases which base royalty on the proceeds at the prevailing market rate, and (3) leases which base royalty on a fixed-rate. Texaco moved for partial summary judgment asking the trial court to find that it had met its royalty obligations only as to the market value leases. The other two types of leases were not before the trial court on Texaco’s motion for partial summary judgment on the issue of underpayment of royalties and are not part of this Court’s review of the issue of underpayment of royalties.

¶ 4 Most of the wells are not subject to a statutory unitization procedure, but a few are.

See

12 O.S.2001, §§ 287.1-.15.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.