District Court, E.D. Wisconsin November 24, 2004, 00-C-1095 (Casey v. Frank)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-11-2004

DECISION AND ORDER

ADELMAN, District Judge.

Pro se petitioner Kevin Casey seeks a writ of habeas corpus challenging his conviction by a jury of sexually assaulting his step-daughter, Kimberly, and a neighbor girl, Melissa, for which he was sentenced to fifteen years in prison followed by twenty years of probation. In his petition, he argues that (1) his lawyers were ineffective, primarily for failing to obtain the case file from his previous attorney, which file contained witness statements undermining the credibility of his accusers; (2) he was deprived of the right of confrontation when the court excused Kimberly from testifying at his preliminary hearing and permitted her to testify via videotaped deposition at trial; (3) he was denied due process when the court precluded him from introducing Kimberly’s prior and allegedly false accusation of sexual assault against her aunt; and (4) he was denied due process because of the cumulative effect of the trial court’s errors.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Although petitioner was tried in 1998, the events relevant to the case commenced in 1992.

A.The 1993 Charge Relating to Melissa

In the summer of 1992, petitioner moved into the home of his girlfriend and soon to be wife, Mary Jo, and her children Kimberly, six, and Timmy, four, in Appleton, Wisconsin. Melissa, who was twelve, lived in the neighborhood. In May 1993, based on Melissa’s allegation and the supporting statement of her friend, Lindsey, the district attorney charged petitioner with sexually assaulting Melissa in September 1992. Eugene Bartman, a public defender, was appointed to represent petitioner. Bartman assigned investigator Terry Young to interview potential witnesses. The statements of some of the witnesses raised questions about the credibility of Melissa’s allegation. Petitioner took two polygraph tests, the first of which was inconclusive, possibly due to a medical condition, but he passed the second.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.