District Court, E.D. Virginia April 23, 2004, CRIM. 03-48-A (United States v. Cuong Gia Le)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-04-2004

MEMORANDUM OPINION

ELLIS, District Judge.

At issue in this multi-count RICO prosecution of the four remaining co-defendants

1

in this matter is whether severance is required under various theories offered

*332

by defendants. More specifically, Cuong Gia Le, the only capital defendant in this case, has moved to sever his trial on three grounds: (1) that the introduction of the out-of-court statements of Vu Hoang Nguyen (a.k.a. Vincent) and Loc Tien Nguyen violates his Sixth Amendment right to confront the witnesses against him, based on

Bruton v. United States,

391 U.S. 123, 88 S.Ct. 1620, 20 L.Ed.2d 476 (1968), and its progeny; (2) that a joint trial of a capital defendant with noncapital co-defendants violates Le’s Eighth Amendment rights; and (3) that a joint trial violates Le’s Fifth Amendment right to notice of the basis for seeking the death penalty. Phu Van Ho has moved to sever his trial on the ground that the introduction of Loc Tien Nguyen’s out-of-court statement violates his Sixth Amendment right under

Bruton.

Finally, Loc Tien Nguyen moves for severance on five grounds: (1)

Bruton;

(2) the theory that his joint trial with a capital defendant violates his Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial because a “death-qualified” jury will be empaneled; (3) conflicting defense theories; (4) disparities in the degree of involvement of co-defendants; and (5) his right to a speedy trial.

For the reasons stated below, severance is not required under

Bruton

or any of the other theories offered by defendants; and their trials may, and appropriately should, proceed jointly.

I.

For a description of the charges and allegations in this matter, see

United States v. Cuong Gia Le et al.,

310 F.Supp.2d 763 (E.D.Va.2004).

2

A brief summary suffices here.

In brief, the government alleges that the four remaining defendants — Cuong Gia Le, Loc Tien Nguyen, Phu Van Ho, and Vu Hoang Nguyen — are active members of a criminal enterprise or gang known as the “Oriental Playboys” or “OPB.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.