Supreme Court of Colorado March 15, 2004, 02SC803 (McIntyre v. Board of County Commissioners)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-2004

combined-opinion

86 P.3d 402 (2004) Kim McINTYRE and Steve McIntyre, Petitioners, v. BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS, GUNNISON COUNTY, Colorado; Sierra Minerals Corp. and Omya Inc., Respondents. No. 02SC803. Supreme Court of Colorado, En Banc. March 15, 2004. *404 Kim McIntyre, Steve McIntyre, Tempe, Arizona, Petitioners Appearing Pro Se. David Baumgarten, Gunnison, Colorado, Attorney for Respondent. Beth A. Dickhaus, Thomas J. Lyons, Denver, Colorado, Attorneys for Amicus Curiae, Colorado Counties, Inc. Justice HOBBS delivered the opinion of the court. We granted certiorari in this case to review the court of appeals decision in Board of County Comm'rs v. McIntyre, No. 01CA2408, 2002 WL 31112520 (Colo.App. Sept.19, 2002).[1] The trial court ruled on summary judgment that Gunnison County had obtained a road by prescription across certain private lands pursuant to section 43-2-201(1)(c), 11 C.R.S. (2002). The court of appeals affirmed the trial court. We reverse. We hold that the county failed to meet the claim of right requirement of section 43-2-201(1)(c) for the establishment of a public road by prescription across the McIntyre lands. I. The petitioners, Kim and Steve McIntyre (McIntyres) own six mining claims near the Town of Marble in Gunnison County. They purchased their property from L.E. Schooley and Associates (Schooley) in 1994. Schooley had acquired the property by virtue of a tax deed in 1960; there is no evidence in the record of a deed in the chain of title that contains a dedication, reservation, or exception for a public road across the McIntyre property. The McIntyre property includes a portion of an old electric tramway route that the Colorado Yule Marble Company operated to *405 haul marble to the Town of Marble from its quarry. The quarry adjoins the McIntyre land. In 1941 the Marble Company ceased operations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.