Idaho Supreme Court April 22, 2004, 24373, 26927 (State v. Lovelace)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-04-2004
*75
BURDICK, Justice.
ON REHEARING
Following the Court’s July 23, 2003, opinion affirming the conviction and remanding the case for resentencing, Lovelace and the State filed separate petitions for rehearing. This Court granted the petitions by order dated November 20, 2003. We do not revisit any of the other issues decided in the original opinion dated July 23, 2003.
ISSUES RAISED ON REHEARING
1. Did the Court improperly review Lovelace’s waiver of counsel and his request for an investigator based solely on court minutes of the pretrial hearing?
2. Did the Court misinterpret Lovelace’s double jeopardy argument against resentencing?
3. Did the Court err in rejecting Lovelace’s ex post facto argument, in light of new case law?
4. Is any error resulting from
Ring
harmless in that the findings necessary to impose the death penalty may be implied from the jury’s verdict of first-degree murder and first-degree kidnapping?
5. Do the provisions of I.C. § 19-5306(e) and Article I, § 22 of the Idaho Constitution provide statutory and constitutional authority for the admission of victim impact evidence in capital cases?
ANALYSIS
1.
Lovelace’s waiver of counsel was valid, and the district court’s decision to deny Lovelace an investigator was not eiror.
On February 12, 2004, the Court entered an order agreeing to take judicial notice of the pretrial hearing held in the district court on July 28, 1997. Contained in the transcript of the proceedings of that date are Lovelace’s request to proceed
pro se
and his request for an investigator.
Our review of the verbatim transcript confirms that the district judge informed Lovelace that he had a constitutional right to counsel and a constitutional right to represent himself. The district judge advised Lovelace of the dangers of self-representation and recommended against going to trial without the assistance of counsel.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit