Court of Appeals of Oregon February 25, 2004, C020047MC; A118587 (State v. Ritzman)
Also known as
United States · · · 25-02-2004
*298
LINDER, J.
In this appeal of appellant’s recommitment
1
to the custody of the Oregon Mental Health Division, appellant raises two issues. First, she argues that the trial court failed to advise her of her rights pursuant to ORS 426.100(1). Second, she argues that the evidence is insufficient to establish, by clear and convincing evidence, that she is mentally ill, dangerous to others, and unlikely to voluntarily comply with treatment. We write only to address the first issue, and we affirm.
ORS 426.100(1) provides:
“At the time the allegedly mentally ill person is brought before the court, the court shall advise the person of the following:
“(a) The reason for being brought before the court;
“(b) The nature of the proceedings;
“(c) The possible results of the proceedings;
“(d) The right to subpoena witnesses; and
“(e) The person’s rights regarding representation by or appointment of counsel.”
To comply with the statute, a trial court in a civil commitment proceeding must either advise the allegedly mentally ill person directly regarding those rights or conduct an examination on the record to determine whether a valid waiver of the right to be advised has been knowingly and voluntarily made.
State v. May,
131 Or App 570, 571, 888 P2d 14 (1994). The trial court’s failure to provide the advice required by the statute is not only error, but it is plain error that we exercise our discretion to consider despite an appellant’s failure to raise and preserve the issue at the hearing.
State v. Tardanico,
132 Or App 230, 231, 888 P2d 15 (1994). But in
*299
reaching the issue, we also consider whether the error was harmless.
State v. Cach,
172 Or App 745, 750 n 4, 19 P3d 992,
rev den,
332 Or 316 (2001). Thus, the remedy for any such error depends on whether the record establishes that the allegedly mentally ill person was otherwise adequately aware of his or her rights or validly waived the right to be advised of them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit