Ohio Court of Appeals November 1, 2004, No. CA2003-12-039. (Ricker v. Parknavy, Unpublished Decision (11-1-2004))

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-2004

OPINION {¶ 1} Defendant-appellant, Thomas Parknavy, appeals a decision of the Madison County Municipal Court, Small Claims Division, awarding judgment in favor of plaintiff-appellee, James Ricker, in a breach of contract action. We affirm the trial court's decision. {¶ 2} Appellee owns a 1976 Triumph TR6 automobile. His son painted the car for him, but discovered that the paint used was defective. The manufacturer of the paint consequently agreed to have a third party repaint the car. In November 2001, appellee contracted with appellant to paint the auto. The paint manufacturer paid appellant $2,200 for the job, and supplied $456 in materials. Appellant's work was poorly executed, resulting in the over spray of paint onto the engine, convertible top, wheels, and inside the trunk. The paint also bubbled in places. Appellant agreed to redo the job, but would not accede to some of appellee's conditions. {¶ 3} Appellee subsequently filed suit, seeking compensation for appellant's failure to complete the job in a workmanlike manner. A hearing was held on the matter at which both parties testified and presented evidence. The trial court concluded that the job was not done in a workmanlike manner and ordered appellant to reimburse appellee $2,656. Appellant appeals, raising thirteen assignments of error. {¶ 4} Appellant's first eight assignments of error allege that the trial court erred in making factual determinations. Specifically, he argues that the trial court erroneously found that the car was delivered to him in November 2001; that another painting company had painted the auto; that both parties presented evidence demonstrating the poor quality of appellant's work; that appellant removed masking put on by appellee; that the convertible top and wheels were marred by over spray; that appellee had installed numerous new parts on the car which were marred by over spray; and that the cost of the paint and materials totaled $456.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.