Ohio Court of Appeals March 5, 2004, No. 03 CO 28. (State v. Sims, Unpublished Decision (3-5-2004))

Also known as

United States · · · 05-03-2004

OPINION {¶ 1} Defendant-appellant Jacqueline Myers Sims appeals the decision of the East Liverpool Municipal Court denying her motion to suppress. Appellant made a statement to law enforcement personnel, however, prior to making that statement she was not Mirandized. Appellant's motion to suppress argued that she was "in custody" at the time she gave a statement and, thus, the failure to Mirandize her requires suppression of the statement. The issue presented to this court is whether appellant was "in custody" at the time she spoke to the patrolman. For the following reasons, the judgment of the trial court is hereby affirmed. STATEMENT OF FACTS {¶ 2} On December 23, 2002, appellant backed her vehicle into a parked gold Grand Prix at the Giant Eagle in Calcutta, Ohio. Appellant immediately left the scene of the accident; however, a witness viewed the accident. This witness provided the owner of the Grand Prix with the license plate number and make of appellant's vehicle and also stated that the driver was a female. {¶ 3} Patrolman Brian McKenzie of the St. Clair Township Police Department was called to investigate this traffic crash. He used the license plate number of the vehicle to determine that appellant was the owner of the vehicle that caused the accident. He then went to appellant's home to question her; however, she was not there. He left instructions with an unidentified female at the residence to have appellant call him because he needed to speak with her about a crash that recently occurred at the Giant Eagle in Calcutta. (Tr. 7). Shortly thereafter, appellant called Patrolman McKenzie and voluntarily agreed to come to the station and talk with him. (Tr. 8). {¶ 4} Upon arriving at the station, Patrolman McKenzie informed appellant he was investigating the crash that occurred at Giant Eagle. Appellant then informed him that she was driving the vehicle that caused the crash. Appellant agreed to give a crash statement and answer a few follow-up questions.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.