Washington Supreme Court November 10, 2004, No. 72485-7 (In re the Personal Restraint of Orange)

Madsen, J.

(concurring in majority) — While I concur in the majority opinion, I write separately because the majority unjustifiably limits appellate review of whether a defendant’s constitutional right to a public trial has been violated, placing form over substance. When applying the five-part test from State v. Bone-Club, 128 Wn.2d 254, 906 P.