Court of Appeals of Washington September 21, 2004, No. 22339-6-III (Basin Paving Co. v. Contractors Bonding & Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-09-2004

Brown, J.

Today, the issue is whether the trial court erred in not awarding attorney fees for an offer of settlement of construction contract claims made to Mike M. Johnson, Inc. (MMJ), by the town of Lind (Lind) under RCW 39.04.240(l)(b). Lind’s offer to settle exceeded the summary judgment award to MMJ, but the trial court held Lind’s offer exceeded the time limit set in the statute when considered from MMJ’s original cross claim as compared to *413MMJ’s later amended cross claim. We agree with the trial court, and affirm.

FACTS

The background facts are found in Basin Paving Co. v. Mike M. Johnson, Inc., 107 Wn. App. 61, 27 P.3d 609 (2001), review denied, 145 Wn.2d 1018 (2002). Relevant now is Lind’s July 7, 1998 $40,000 offer under RCW 39.04.240-(l)(b) to settle MMJ’s cross claim in a construction dispute. The statute sets a 120-day time limit for making settlement offers.

By February 19, 1998, MMJ completed service and filing of its initial cross claim against Lind. MMJ alleged breach of express and implied warranties, breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and breach of contract. By May 14, 1998, MMJ completed service and filing of an amended cross claim, which added estoppel theories. Lind’s settlement offer was served 138 days after the initial cross claim and 54 days after the amended cross claim. The settlement offer provided that Lind would seek attorney fees and costs under RCW 39.04.240(l)(b) if an award was less than the offer.

MMJ rejected Lind’s offer. Lind successfully requested summary judgment against MMJ and received an order limiting the judgment against it to $7,290.12. Lind then requested attorney fees and costs, arguing it had prevailed under its offer of settlement, which had offered $40,000 to settle. The court denied Lind’s request, concluding Lind’s settlement offer was untimely under RCW 39.04.240(l)(b) because the settlement offer came more than 120 days from the initial cross claim. Lind appealed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.