Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 2, 2004 (Hilsman v. Sarwil Associates, L.P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-12-2004

Spain, J.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Ferradino, J.), entered March 30, 2004 in Saratoga County, which denied defendants’ motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.

Plaintiffs commenced this negligence action to recover for knee injuries allegedly sustained by plaintiff Charles Hilsman, Jr. (hereinafter the child) on August 11, 1998 when he—an 11 year old using crutches due to a broken ankle—slipped and fell on a wet floor just inside an entrance to the Wilton Mall, located in the Town of Wilton, Saratoga County. Asserting a storm in progress defense and lack of notice, defendants moved for summary judgment. Supreme Court denied the motion, finding triable issues of fact precluding summary judgment. On defendants’ appeal, we affirm.

We begin with an overview of the recognized parameters of the storm in progress defense. It is well settled that a landowner’s obligation to take reasonable measures to correct storm-created snow and ice conditions does not commence until after the storm has ceased (see Parker v Rust Plant Servs., Inc., 9 AD3d 671, 672 [2004]; Campagnano v Highgate Manor of Rensselaer, 299 AD2d 714, 715 [2002]; Lyons v Cold Brook Cr. Realty Corp., 268 AD2d 659, 659 [2000]). This defense evolved in this state in recognition of “the realities of problems caused by winter weather” (Fusco v Stewart’s Ice Cream Co., 203 AD2d 667, 668 [1994]), that is, as “a common-sense rule arising from the fact that snow and ice conditions are unpredictable, natural hazards against which no one can insure and which in their nature cannot immediately be alleviated” (Valentine v State of New York, 197 Misc 972, 975 [1950], affd 277 App Div 1069 [1950]; see Kelly v Manhattan Ry. Co., 112 NY 443, 452-453 [1889]).

Over time, the defense has been extended to apply to dangerous conditions occurring inside a building entrance caused by winter storms (see Zonitch v Plaza at Latham, 255 AD2d 808, 808-809 [1998]; see also Hussein v New York City Tr. Auth.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.