City of New York Municipal Court August 16, 2004 (People v. Scivolette)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-08-2004

OPINION OF THE COURT

Ronald J. McGaw, J.

Defendant is charged with auto stripping in the third degree in violation of Penal Law § 165.09, and criminal mischief in the *886fourth degree in violation of Penal Law § 145.00. The evidence allegedly consists primarily of the defendant’s fingerprints which were found on and above the driver’s door handle, as well as on other areas of the vehicle.

Defendant has moved for his release pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law § 170.70 on the basis that “fingerprints found on an item that was accessible to the general public [are] not sufficient to convict” a defendant, and therefore not sufficient to sustain the formation of an information.* The defendant states that the Appellate Division, Second Department, “has twice ruled that fingerprints found on an item that was accessible to the general public [are] not sufficient to convict,” and cites two cases in support of this statement.

In one case cited by the defendant, the only evidence tending to establish guilt consisted of fingerprints found on a jewelry box recovered outside the complainant’s apartment in an area accessible to the public. In this circumstance, the Appellate Division ruled that such evidence “was not legally sufficient to establish the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v Collins, 150 AD2d 476, 476 [2d Dept 1989].) The judgment of conviction was reversed and the indictment dismissed.

In the second case cited by the defendant, the evidence presented to a grand jury consisted largely of the testimony of a detective who had investigated the alleged burglary of a church. (People v Jacob, 55 AD2d 961 [2d Dept 1977].) As stated by the Court:

“[E]ntry had been gained by means of the removal of louvers from a window at the side of the building. The window was in a ‘fenced-in area’; access could only be had by climbing over a 12-foot-high wall and fence . . .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.