Massachusetts Appeals Court May 11, 2004, No. 02-P-1159 (Framingham Heavy Equipment Co. v. John T. Callahan & Sons, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-2004

Dreben, J.

In December of 1997, the plaintiff, Framingham Heavy Equipment Company, Inc. (Framingham), an excavation subcontractor, entered into a written contract with a general contractor, John T. Callahan & Sons, Inc. (Callahan), to perform certain site work at the Lynn English High School for $594,000. At that time Callahan already had entered into a contract with the city of Lynn (city) for renovations and an addition to the school. Even before the subcontract was signed, unforeseen site conditions, including discovery of large quantities of peat and other materials unsuitable for a building foundation, were discovered beneath the site,2 which, as the excavations progressed, required extensive work beyond the scope of the subcontract. Although Framingham demanded payment for these and other changes, and although Callahan applied for payment for most of these changes from the city, by January 15, 1999, Framingham had received only a very small portion of the amount requested. On that date it brought this action claiming that Callahan was in breach of contract and seeking damages (alternatively in quantum meruit) of “at least $678,757.94,” most or all of which was for work required by changes requested by the general contractor or the city’s architect. The amount sought included work performed pursuant to a “construction change directive,” a matter discussed later in this opinion. Callahan counterclaimed, alleging that it was Framingham, rather than Callahan, who was in breach of contract by walking, off the job. After a four week jury-waived trial, a judge of the Superior Court, in a careful and well-reasoned memorandum, found Callahan in breach for nonpayment, excused Framingham from further performance, and entered a judgment for Framing-ham which, as amended, included damages of $572,049.64, of which all but $6,500 was for changes not covered in the original contract. He also awarded prejudgment interest of $186,568.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.