Massachusetts Appeals Court August 20, 2004, No. 02-P-1714 (Commonwealth v. Kincaid)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-08-2004
Cypher, J.
In September, 2001, a Superior Court jury found the defendant, Aaron Kincaid, guilty of four counts of aggravated rape (G. L. c. 265, § 22).1 The theory of the Commonwealth’s case was that the defendant had committed the rape as a joint venturer with Richard Lampron. The theory of *658the defense was consent. At the time of the trial, Richard Lam-pron was a fugitive from justice. The judge and counsel had taken care to prevent this fact from coming to the jury’s attention.
In May, 2002, the defendant filed a motion for a new trial, specifically for postverdict inquiry of the jurors. The defendant alleged that the jurors had learned that Lampron had fled and that this information constituted an extraneous influence on the jury. The trial judge conducted an evidentiary hearing and inquired of all of the deliberating jurors. The judge ordered a new trial after concluding that the jury had been exposed to extraneous matter (Lampron’s flight) and that the Commonwealth had not proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not prejudiced by the introduction of the extraneous matter. Commonwealth v. Fidler, 377 Mass. 192, 201 (1979). The Commonwealth appeals, claiming that (1) the judge erred in finding that the jury had been exposed to extraneous matter and (2) even if the jury had been so exposed, the Commonwealth had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was not prejudiced.2
1. Background. We briefly summarize the relevant evidence against the defendant and the relevant procedural history.
a. The Commonwealth’s case. The victim, Gail,3 testified that the defendant and Lampron engaged in sexual acts with her against her will, on September 23, 1998, while she was stupefied. Two friends of the defendant testified that they had seen a videotape of the defendant and Lampron engaged in sexual acts with the victim while she appeared to be unconscious.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit