Court of Appeals of Arkansas June 30, 2004, CA 03-916 (Strack v. Capital Services Group, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-2004

lead-opinion

Wendell L. Griffen, Judge.

Appellant appeals from an order granting appellee's motion for summary judgment. Because the order did not dispose of all of the claims pled in the lawsuit, it is not a final, appealable order, and we therefore dismiss the appeal.

Appellant is the former owner of a five-percent interest in appellee Capital Services Group (CSG). Following his ouster from the company in November 2001, appellant received the first of several quarterly distribution checks, as provided by the company’s Members Agreement. Appellant disputed the amount of the check and raised other questions concerning CSG’s calculation of its distributable income, but he ultimately offered to settle the total amount he would be owed on quarterly distributions for $40,000, less amounts already received. CSG accepted the settlement, and appellant deposited the settlement check.

Thereafter, appellant informed CSG that he would continue to assert claims against it, prompting CSG to seek a declaratory judgment that it had no further liability to appellant. Appellant answered and counterclaimed that the settlement was tainted by fraud and was not an effective release of his claims. He also sought monetary damages for: 1) insurance fraud, based on an allegation that CSG was participating in an illegal commission-sharing scheme; 2) securities fraud, based on an allegation that, in repurchasing his interest after the ouster, CSG failed to disclose material information; 3) civil conspiracy in connection with the alleged insurance scheme.

CSG filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing that appellant’s claims were barred by the settlement. A hearing was held, during which appellant’s causes of action for insurance fraud, securities fraud, and civil conspiracy were not discussed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.