Circuit Court of the 9th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Orange County May 26, 2004, Case No. CL02-81 (Wenke v. Emerald Lake Homes, L.C.)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-05-2004
By Judge Daniel R. Bouton
I am writing to advise you of the court’s ruling in connection with the above referenced Motions for Summary Judgment
Issues Before the Court
Two separate motions for summary judgment have been filed by Century 21 and argued by counsel. The first motion addresses whether the restrictive covenant that confers on lot owners in the Lake of the Woods Subdivision a right of first refusal with respect to the sale of any adjoining lot is void ab initio under the rationale of Lake of the Woods Association, Inc. v. McHugh, 238 Va. 1, 380 S.E.2d 872 (1989). The second motion states that Virginia’s economic loss rule prevents the plaintiffs from recovering against Century 21 in this case. For the reasons that follow, the court will only analyze the second motion for summary judgment.
Discussion and Analysis
To begin with, the plaintiffs claim that the economic loss rule does not prohibit them from maintaining an action against Century 21. They rely primarily on the reasoning of Miller v. Quarles, 242 Va. 343, 410 S.E.2d 639 (1991), in support of their position. Before examining the plaintiffs’ argument regarding the application of Miller to the present case, it is important to *86reiterate that the economic loss doctrine was not modified, curtailed, or diminished by the holding in the case. This point was emphasized by the Supreme Court in the more recent case of Gerald M. Moore & Son, Inc. v. Drewry, 251 Va. 277, 467 S.E.2d 811 (1996). There, the court emphasized that Miller does not alter the long established rule that requires privity of contract before a party can be held liable for economic loss: “An agent can be held liable for negligent performance of a contract to which he is not a party but to which his principal is a party. ... However, even if an agent’s negligence is established, absent privity of contract, Virginia’s economic loss doctrine precludes the recovery of damages based on economic loss alone.... Our recent case of Miller v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit