Supreme Court of Florida May 13, 2004, No. SC03-2108 (Inquiry Concerning a Judge, No. 03-98 re Andrews)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-05-2004

PER CURIAM.

We review the recommendation of the Investigative Panel of the Judicial Qualifications Commission (JQC) that Judge Robert Lance Andrews receive the sanction of a public reprimand for his judicial misconduct.1 We approve the recommendation.

The JQC filed charges against Judge Andrews, alleging that while he presided over the case of Carnato v. Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp., he made various inappropriate statements concerning the defendant, Novartis, in an interview with a reporter for the Daily Business Review. It was alleged he made the following statements:

1. Novartis was trying to bury the plaintiffs in documents;

2. Novartis has only itself to blame for developments in the litigation;

3. The defense’s strategy backfired; and

4. The entire database [the Special Master is creating at Novartis Pharmaceuticals’ expense] would provide a national plaintiffs blueprint for filing suit against Novartis over Parlodel [the drug in the case.]

The comments were made in reference to a discovery request made by the plaintiff in the case. The defendant, Novartis, responded to the discovery request by producing over one million documents.2 Novartis claimed that the documents were privileged and requested an in-camera inspection of the documents. Judge Andrews appointed a special master to review the documents, at great expense to Novartis. Novartis then sought to have the in-camera inspection suspended.

The JQC alleged that the statements were inappropriate and evidenced a bias against the defendant, Novartis. The JQC and Judge Andrews presented a stipulation to this Court pursuant to article V, section 12 of the Florida Constitution, and rule 6(j) of the JQC’s rules. In that stipulation, Judge Andrews admitted to the conduct alleged and did not contest the findings of guilt and recommendation of discipline. The Investigative Panel of the JQC recommended a public reprimand of Judge Andrews.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.