District Court of Appeal of Florida July 28, 2004, Nos. 4D03-3661, 4D03-3751 (Choxom v. Bankers Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-2004

PER CURIAM.

The issue raised on this appeal is whether there is coverage under a commercial general liability policy; which excludes accidents arising out of the use of an automobile, where there' is a claim that an employer negligently failed to train his employee not to leave the keys in the ignition. We agree with the well reasoned opinion of the trial court which provides:

Counsel stipulated to all material facts. Petitioner, Bankers Insurance *948Company, issued a commercial general liability insurance policy to Respondent Michael Dean Moye d/b/a Moye’s Irrigation (“Policy”). Moye employed Astel Soloman. Moye owned a 1986 Dodge van which Soloman used. Soloman left the keys in the vehicle and the vehicle unattended. The vehicle was stolen by Donald Stephen Flewellen. Flewellen negligently operated the vehicle, causing an accident which injured Luis Alberto Jiminez and Moisés Isaías Choxom and killed Salome Cutz and Pedro Ronaldo Choxom.

Bankers has brought this declaratory judgment action against those injured, the personal representatives of the decedents’ estates, Moye, Soloman, and Flewellen, seeking a declaration that the Policy affords no coverage for the accident.

Section II of the Policy provides:

2. Exclusions

This insurance does not apply to

g. Aircraft, Auto or Watercraft

“Bodily injury” or “property damage” arising out of the ownership, maintenance, use or entrustment to others of any ... “auto” ... owned or operated by ... any insured.

The parties agree that the van is an “auto” and Moye and Soloman were insureds under the Policy.

An accident “arises out of’ the use of a vehicle in this context if

1. it arises out of the inherent nature of the vehicle;

2. it arises within the territorial limits of the vehicle and the use, loading, or unloading has not terminated; and

3. the vehicle does not merely contribute to cause the condition which produces the injury but, itself, produces the injury.

Farrer v. United States Fidelity and Guaranty Co., 809 So.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.