Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit March 30, 2004, 02-3931 (United States v. James Thomas McBride)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-03-2004

OPINION

GILMAN, Circuit Judge.

James Thomas McBride was convicted of (1) presenting a false claim against the IRS, and (2) various obstruction of justice and bankruptcy fraud charges based upon certain financial transactions he initiated that were related to a tax evasion case against his girlfriend. He insisted on proceeding without the assistance of counsel at his trial. The jury convicted him on all counts. McBride seeks to overturn his conviction on the basis that his waiver of counsel was ineffective and because the evidence against him was allegedly insufficient. For the reasons set forth below, we AFFIRM the district court’s determination that McBride effectively waived his right to counsel at all stages of the proceedings and that there was sufficient evidence to convict him on Counts 2-6, but REVERSE McBride’s conviction on Count 1 because there was insufficient evidence to support the verdict on that charge. We also VACATE McBride’s sentence and REMAND for resentencing consistent with this opinion.

I. BACKGROUND

A. Factual background

Katina Kefalos was convicted by a jury, in proceedings before District Judge Alge-non L. Marbley, of evading $12,990.67 in federal income taxes. Kefalos was McBride’s girlfriend. During the course of her trial, Kefalos fired the two attorneys^ — -David Axelrod and Terry Sherman — who were appointed to represent her. Prior to Kefalos’s sentencing, McBride sent a check for the $12,990.67 to IRS revenue agent Margaret Nypaver, who had unsuccessfully attempted to collect this sum from Kefalos and who testified against her at trial. McBride knew that his check would “bounce” because it was drawn on an account that he had closed one year earlier. He then submitted bad checks from the same account to the Franklin County Treasurer’s Office to purportedly pay the real estate taxes for the first half of 2001 on the residences of Judge Marbley, attorneys Axelrod and Sherman, and agent Nypaver.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.