Connecticut Appellate Court October 26, 2004, AC 24629 (Shapiro v. Hillside Village Condominium Ass'n)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-10-2004

Opinion

PER CURIAM.

The plaintiffs, Vladimir Shapiro and Gina Shapiro, appeal from the judgment rendered in favor of the defendants, Hillside Village Condominium Association Inc. (Hillside), Alex Braylyan and David Braylyan, following a jury trial. On appeal, the plaintiffs claim that the trial court committed plain error when *730it allowed Hillside’s counsel to make a missing witness argument to the jury, pursuant to General Statutes § 52-216c, concerning witnesses who had not been proven to be available to testify. We affirm the judgment of the trial court.

The plaintiffs’ action arose out of injuries and damages sustained when Vladimir Shapiro was stabbed by an unknown assailant while attending a private party hosted by the Braylyans at the Hillside clubhouse in Hamden. The plaintiffs contend that the court made an obvious and egregious error by allowing counsel for Hillside to make an improper missing witness argument that tipped the balance between the conflicting testimony of Vladimir Shapiro and Alex Braylyan.

Counsel for Hillside made the following statements in his closing argument: “What is the best evidence? How do we learn what happened that evening? We learn through testimony of witnesses. We heard from [Alex Braylyan’s friend] Gene Zeldon, we heard from Katie [Fedolova], we heard from [Vladimir Shapiro]. Did we hear from [Vladimir Shapiro’s friend] Igor [Bedziet-skiy]? Was Igor here? We don’t even know Igor’s last name, but I think we found it in the police report. It’s referenced in the police report. We didn’t hear from Igor. The guy [Vladimir Shapiro] went to the party with. Did we hear from [Vladimir Shapiro’s friend] Arsen [Grigorian]? No. He wasn’t around, he didn’t testify. How about [Vladimir Shapiro’s friend] Vladislav [Gor-man]? Didn’t hear from him either. Now, let’s think about this, and I heard [the plaintiffs’ counsel say you should] use common sense, does it make sense. Take a minute, let’s think about this.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.