Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit October 7, 2004, 03-1528 (Arnold C. Bilstad, Bradley H. Buchanan, Alan W. Martilla and Archie Woodworth v. George Wakalopulos and Eduardo R. Urgiles)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-10-2004

LINN, Circuit Judge.

Arnold C. Bilstad, Bradley H. Buchanan, Alan W. Martilla, and Archie Woodworth (collectively “Bilstad”) appeal from: (1) a March 31, 2003 decision of the United States Patent and Trademark Office Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences (“Board”) and (2) a May 23, 2003 decision of the Board on reconsideration awarding judgment in Interference No. 104,832 to George Wakalopulos and Eduardo R. Ur-giles (collectively ‘Wakalopulos”).

Bilstad v. Wakalopulos,

Inter. No. 104,832, Paper 69 (Bd. Pat. App. & Inter. May 23, 2003)

(“Reconsideration Decision”); Bilstad v. Wakalopulos,

Inter. No. 104,832, Paper 62 (Bd. Pat App. & Inter. Mar. 31, 2003)

(“Original Decision”).

Because the Board’s claim construction was correct, and because the Board did not abuse its discretion in dismissing Bilstad’s motion for leave to belatedly add additional claims to the count, we affirm those portions of the Board’s decision. However, because the Board failed to apply the correct standard in deciding whether Bilstad’s disclosure supported the count, we vacate that portion of the Board’s decision and remand.

I. BACKGROUND

This interference was declared on March 30, 2002 between an application of Bilstad, Application Serial No. 09/294,964, filed April 20, 1999, and a patent of Wakalopu-los, U.S. Patent No. 6,140,657 (“the '657 patent”), filed March 17, 1999 and issued October 31, 2000. The claimed subject matter relates to an apparatus for sterilizing three-dimensional objects using ionizing radiation without affecting the target objects in a deleterious manner.

Bilstad provoked the interference by copying claims 1, 5-8, 11, and 16-17 of the '657 patent into Bilstad’s pending application as claims 57-64, as well as adding a paraphrased version of Wakalopulos’s claim 18 as claim 65. The Board declared the interference, designating claim 1 of the '657 patent as the only count and identifying Bilstad claims 57-65 as corresponding to the count.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.