Supreme Court of New Hampshire May 25, 2004, No. 2003-493 (Boccia v. City of Portsmouth)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-05-2004

Galway, J.

The petitioners, abutters to property owned by the intervenor, Raymond A. Ramsey, appeal an order of the Superior Court (T. Nadeau, J.) affirming the grant of six variances by the zoning board of adjustment (ZBA) for the respondent, City of Portsmouth (City). We reverse and remand.

Ramsey owns a seven-acre parcel of undeveloped land located at the intersection of Kearsarge Way and Market Street Extension in Portsmouth. When he purchased the land in 1985, it was zoned for residential use. Ramsey wanted to construct a 100-room hotel on the property. Accordingly, in 1987, he filed a petition for rezoning with the City, which was denied. His appeal of the original denial was unsuccessful.

Following a second unsuccessful attempt to have the property rezoned, he again appealed pursuant to RSA 677:4 (Supp. 2003). The Superior Court (McHugh, J.) granted his petition to rezone the property to “general business” to permit a hotel use. See Ramsey v. City of Portsmouth, No. 96-E-374 (Rockingham County Super. Ct., Nov. 23, 1998.) In reaching its decision, the court considered that the City had adopted a new zoning ordinance and a new master plan since Ramsey first applied for rezoning. In addition, major changes had occurred in the area, including the construction of a 125-room Marriott Hotel directly across from the subject property, which made the City’s denial of the rezoning petition unreasonable. The court’s order rezoning the property referred to Ramsey’s plan for a 100-room hotel.

After the rezoning, Ramsey filed applications with the ZBA seeking approval of six area variances in connection with the development of the 100-room hotel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.