Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit March 9, 2004, No. 02-17123 (Siddiqui v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-03-2004
ALARCÓN, Circuit Judge.
Zariq and Greta Siddiqui, Joseph, Richard and Elizabeth Vullo, and Vullo, Siddi-qui & Associates, Ltd. (“VSA”) (collectively, “Appellants”) appeal from the district court’s limitation of its award under 26 U.S.C. § 7431 to a total of $6,000 in statutory damages, and the denial of punitive damages for the unauthorized disclosure of income tax return information. We affirm because we conclude that only one act of disclosure occurred. We also hold that under § 7431 punitive damages are precluded absent proof of actual damages.
I
On June 26, 1997, agents of the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) conducted a search for evidence at the residences of Zariq Siddiqui and Joseph Vullo, and the corporate offices of VSA. VSA operated a business called “Bagel Nosh.” The criminal investigation of Appellants continued for more than four years.
On October 24, 1998, approximately one hundred people attended IRS Special Agent Greg Heck’s retirement party at a restaurant in Tempe, Arizona. The guests included active and retired IRS employees, federal prosecutors, agents from other law enforcement agencies, and private tax attorneys, including two lawyers who were representing Appellants in the ongoing criminal investigation.
During the party, some of the guests “roasted” Special Agent Heck about his career as an IRS agent. In response to his friends’ attempts at humor, Special Agent Heck read a prepared “counter-roast” and presented mementos to accompany his remarks. When he gave a Bagel Nosh baseball cap to a colleague, he commented as follows:
And from the owner of Bagel Brothers, Bagel Nosh, I almost said that right, Bagel Nosh. An item of evidence that you missed at the search of the Vullo’s [sic] and ah Siddiqui’s [sic] house. They want you to have it. It says tax evasion evidence inside. It’s still a pending case.
Embroidered on the back of the cap was a citation to 26 U.S.C. § 7201.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit