Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit July 13, 2004, No. 03-1002 (Gearns v. Berghuis)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-07-2004
ROGERS, Circuit Judge.
In this appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus, the question presented is whether a defendant suffers a violation of his Confrontation Clause and Due Process Clause rights when a prosecutor elicits from a government witness, in the presence of the jury, an assertion of the Fifth Amendment privilege. Because the witness asserted the privilege in response to a foundational question, and the assertion did not create an inference establishing an element of the state’s case, we affirm the judgment of the district court.
Gearns was convicted by a state jury of second degree murder and of using a firearm in the perpetration of a felony. The facts of the underlying offenses are set forth in detail in the Supreme Court of Michigan’s opinion, People v. Gearns, 457 Mich. 170, 577 N.W.2d 422, 425-26 (1998)(“Geams I”), and need not be restated here. At trial, the prosecution intended to introduce evidence that Gearns’s brother, Gregory, had assisted Gearns in disposing of the victim’s body and cleaning up the remaining evidence of the crime. Prior to trial, prosecutors had negotiated an agreement with Gregory that, if he agreed to testify against his brother, he would be immune from a charge of accessory after the fact to murder.
At trial, however, Gregory’s attorney indicated to the court that Gregory would refuse to testify unless the prosecution agreed to grant him immunity as well from being charged for the underlying murder. Although the trial court warned Gregory and his attorney that it would hold Gregory in contempt if he refused to testify, Gregory’s attorney insisted that Gregory would assert the Fifth Amendment privilege unless he received immunity for the homicide. The trial court stated that it did not believe the witness’s Fifth Amendment privilege to be valid and that it intended to hold Gregory in contempt if he refused to answer questions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit