Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit July 14, 2004, No. 01-6585 (Smith v. Toyota Motor Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-07-2004
BATCHELDER, Circuit Judge.
Nathaniel Smith appeals the judgment entered on the jury’s verdict in favor of *49the defendants, Toyota Motor Corporation and Toyota Motor Sales, USA, Inc. (“Toyota”), and the orders of the trial court denying Smith’s motions in limine in this product liability action. We AFFIRM the orders and the judgment.
This product liability action stems from a one-vehicle accident that occurred on May 5, 1999, in Muhlenberg County, Kentucky. Plaintiff Nathaniel Smith and his friend, Rodney Dunn, were the only occupants of the 1998 Toyota Tacoma pickup truck involved in the accident. Smith was driving the truck on Highway 81, “the Levee Road,” in the rain. Smith inadvertently dropped the right wheels of the truck off the pavement, and as he attempted to bring the vehicle back up onto the roadway, the rear tires slid down the steep slippery slope to the right. The truck rolled over several times before finally coming to rest on its wheels. By all accounts, the roof of the truck was crushed at least nine inches on the driver’s side. Smith was found still belted into the driver’s seat; his head appearing to be pinned down by the vehicle’s crushed roof. He suffered injuries to his cervical vertebrae, severe hematoma to his spinal cord, and a tearing of ligaments and tendons, and remains a permanent quadriplegic who requires caregiver assistance on a daily basis.
Smith brought this product liability action against Toyota on January 25, 2000, alleging that the Tacoma had been defectively designed and manufactured, and that those defects had caused him serious injury. Before trial, Smith filed a “Plaintiffs Admission of Fault,” stating that he had been at fault for “causing the wheels on the right side of the vehicle to drop off the pavement.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit