Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit November 3, 2004, No. 03-35425; D.C. No. CV-02-00617-RSL (Thrifty-Payless Inc. v. Ennen Food Stores Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-11-2004
MEMORANDUM***
Movants-Appellants Ennen Food Stores, Inc., (“EFS”), a Washington corporation, and Brown & Cole Stores, LLC, *799(“Brown & Cole”), a Washington limited liability corporation, appeal from the District Court’s Order Granting Appellee Thrifty Payless, Inc.’s (“Thrifty”) Motion for Summary Judgment, Denying Brown & Cole’s Motion for Summary Judgment, and Granting a permanent injunction in favor of Thrifty.
The parties to the appeal lease properties in the Lynden Towne Plaza Shopping Center (“Shopping Center”) in Lynden, Whatcom County, Washington. The parties’ dispute involves various leases and covenants regarding the use of premises presently occupied by the two principal tenants, Brown & Cole, who operates the supermarket, and Thrifty, who operates the pharmacy. The specific leases at issue include a lease entered into between the original owner of the shopping center and Associated Grocer’s Inc. (“the AG lease”), and a sublease signed contemporaneously between Associated Grocer’s Inc. (“AG”), and its initial subleasee, EFS (“the Sublease”). Brown & Cole currently operate the supermarket under the sublease.
The instant dispute arose when Brown & Cole underwent reconstruction of its supermarket to include an in-store pharmacy. Thrifty maintains that an in-store pharmacy would violate the various leases and covenants binding the parties, and consequently, sought a preliminary injunction in district court. The district court ultimately issued a permanent injunction prohibiting Brown & Cole from operating a pharmacy on the supermarket premises.
DISCUSSION
a. Express or Implied Restrictive Covenant
Appellants Brown & Cole and EFS (collectively “Appellants”) maintain that Thrifty is ultimately arguing that the lease at issue contains an implied restrictive covenant. Appellants state that pursuant to Washington law, Thrifty cannot establish an implied covenant.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit