Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit December 28, 2004, No. 03-4299 (Arnett v. Kemp)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-2004

Order

While awaiting release on parole, James Arnett filed this action under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. His wife Ann and their son Nehemiah also are listed as plaintiffs, but their presence does not affect the analysis. Ar-nett contended that Indiana would enforce a standard condition of parole for violent sex offenders: that the parolee have no contact with children, unless the parole board approves or the offender completes a treatment program. Ind.Code § 11 — 13— 3-4(g)(l)(B). Arnett, who had been convicted of raping his former fiancée, enrolled in a treatment program but had been thrown out for discussing his religious beliefs. That left the no-contact condition in place, requiring him to have no contact with his son for the six years of his parole’s scheduled duration — and to live apart from his wife, since she takes care of their child. Keeping family members separate would violate the constitutional rights of all three, the complaint contended. Arnett asked for a preliminary injunction, and when the district court denied this on procedural grounds (deeming preliminary relief precipitate), Arnett immediately appealed. While the appeal was pending, Arnett was released.

The record does not show whether Ar-nett has asked the board for permission to live with his son under Ind.Code § 11-13-3-4(g)(l)(B)(i), and, if he did so, what answer it gave. Before release from prison he did send a letter to a parole officer and received the answer that no contact with minors is a uniform condition of parole for sex offenders, but the statute expressly authorizes the board to make exceptions, and it is not clear whether (since his release) Arnett has made a proper application directly to the board. This also means that we also do not know whether there is a live case or controversy. The state’s brief does not address this but does suggest that Arnett’s parole has been or is being revoked; if so, then the controversy is moot unless it is apt to recur when next Arnett becomes eligible.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.