High Court of American Samoa June 16, 2004, CR No. 10-03; CR No. 21-03 (American Samoa Government v. Majhor)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-06-2004

ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR CHANGE OF VENUE AND A SURVEY EXPERT

On Feburary 5, 2004, Defendant Richard Majhor (“Majhor”) moved for change of venue and for appointment of a survey expert. Along with a host of other motions, we heard argument for the two motions on March 4,2004. For the reasons below, we deny both motions.

Discussion

Due process entitles a defendant to “a panel of impartial, ‘indifferent’ jurors.” American Samoa Gov’t v. Wei Li Fang, 7 A.S.R.3d 104, 106 (Trial Div. 2003) (citations omitted). An inquiry into actual jury bias is premature when jury voir dire has not yet been conducted. Id. at 107. To show jury bias at this stage, the defendant must meet the burden of showing an atmosphere of presumed prejudice. Id. Rarely shown, presumed prejudice “is reserved for exceptional cases where the influence of the news media negatively pervades the proceedings, either in the community or courtroom.” Id. (citations omitted). Stated another way, the defendants “carry a heavy burden of showing oversaturation of highly sensationalized news coverage.” Id.

Applying an analysis similar to that used in Wei Li Fang, we find that Majhor has failed to meet his burden. Majhor fails to introduce any evidence of prejudiced radio, television coverage, or general public sentiment to show oversaturation. Refraining from making conclusions on Majhor’s guilt or innocence, the tendered newspaper articles make clear that Majhor has allegedly committed crimes, is charged with these crimes, and faces ongoing court proceedings.

By characterizing possibly inflammatory statements as beliefs and by primarily reporting facts, the most opinionated article lacks high sensationalism. It reports that “today commemorates the . . . possible murder of Wyatt Jr. [the victim] at the hands of seven defendants.” (Def. *175Supplemental Br. for Mot. for Change of Venue, Ex. A at 1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.