United States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. New York August 31, 2004, No. 04-10109 (In re Peterson)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-08-2004
MICHAEL J. KAPLAN, Bankruptcy Judge.
This case squarely presents an issue that the Second Circuit in In re Pond, 252 F.3d 122 (2nd Cir.2001), declined to address when it explicitly (but without guidance) rejected the advice given by one Panel of the 11th Circuit in In re Dickerson, 222 F.3d 924 (11th Cir.2000).
In the Dickerson case, the Panel stated that if it were not constrained by the 11th Circuit’s “prior panel” rule (of horizontal stare decisis), it would reject the notion that a wholly unsecured mortgage may be avoided despite Nobelman. The Panel said “... [Providing ‘antimodification’ protection to mortgagees where the value of the mortgage property exceeds the senior mortgagee’s claim by at least one cent ... but denying that same protection to junior mortgagees who lack that penny of equity, places too much weight upon the valuation process. As we have noted ‘[vjaluation outside the actual market place is inherently inexact ...’ Given the unavoidable imprecision and uncertainty of the valuation process, we think that choosing to draw a bright line at this point is akin to attempting to draw a bright line in the fog. ” [Emphasis mine.]
The Second Circuit in Pond explicitly noted that dictum in Dickerson when it chose to align this Circuit with the prior ruling by the Eleventh Circuit, and with other authorities.
Here now is a case in which the Debtor’s appraiser competently appraised the home at $113,000, and the Second Mortgagee’s appraiser just-as-competently appraised the home at $125,000. The First Mortgage lien is $114,118. The Second Mortgage payoff is approximately $22,200.
The Debtor's Plan will pay 5% to unsecured creditors. Consequently, the Second Mortgagee will receive $22,000 plus a “present value additive” if the Court finds the home to be worth at least $1,118.01 more than the Debtor’s $113,000 appraisal, but will receive only $1100 otherwise — a difference of more than $20,900.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit