United States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. Wisconsin November 24, 2004, Bankruptcy No. 03-15105; Adversary No. 03-00152 (Crawley v. Aurora Loan Services)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-11-2004
MEMORANDUM DECISION
ROBERT D. MARTIN, Bankruptcy Judge.
The debtors filed a Chapter 13 petition on July 10, 2003, and a Complaint To Determine Validity Of Lien on July 30, 2003. On stipulated facts, the parties submitted the case to the court for resolution on cross motions for summary judgment.
Prior to November 15, 2002, Wells Fargo Bank held a properly-recorded first mortgage on the debtors’ home in the amount of $54,900.00. Household Mortgage held a properly-recorded second mortgage on the home in the amount of $25,001.00.
On November 15, 2002, the debtors refinanced the first and second mortgages by a new note and mortgage given to Field-stone Mortgage Company (“Fieldstone”). The Wells Fargo and Household Mortgage mortgages were satisfied in full. Field-stone loan proceeds were also used to pay property taxes due. K & M Title Company closed the loan as settlement agent for Fieldstone. Due to K & M’s negligence, the mortgage was not recorded. The debtors made mortgage payments until July 2003 when they filed their Chapter 13 Petition. The debtors listed Fieldstone’s claim as unsecured for $81,690.38. The home had a value as of July 10, 2003 of $60,000, and a liquidation value of $54,000.00.
The debtors want to use the trustee’s § 544(a)(3) power to avoid Fieldstone’s lien thereby rendering Fieldstone’s claim unsecured, non-priority, and dischargeable. They may not do so.
Fieldstone argues that it is entitled to equitable subrogation, to wit: that it is entitled to take the place of the erstwhile secured creditors, Wells Fargo and Household Mortgage, by virtue of having paid the debts owed to them. Fieldstone goes on to claim that its mortgage should be deemed recorded as of the date the Wells Fargo and Household Mortgage mortgages were recorded by virtue of having paid those mortgages for the debtors’ benefit. Fieldstone is not entitled to subrogation.
Subrogation in this context is a matter of state law.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit