Loudoun County Circuit Court August 4, 2004, Case No. (Law) 29885 (Laguna v. Wallace)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-08-2004

BY JUDGE JAMES H. CHAMBLIN

This case came before the Court on July 9, 2004, for argument on the Demurrers of Defendants Robert William Wallace, Harvey Dove, d/b/aH. A. Dove & Sons (“Dove”), and S & N Communications, Inc. (“S & N”), to the Second Amended Motion for Judgment.

For the reasons that follow, the Demurrer of Wallace is overruled, except that it is sustained as to the claims against him in Count III of the Second Amended Motion for Judgment. Also, the Demurrer of Dove and S & N is sustained as to Counts V and VI, as to any claim that they are liable for the negligent acts of Wallace and Mitchell under the doctrines of respondeat superior and agency, and as to any claim that they are liable for negligent hiring and retention merely because of the negligent acts of Wallace and Mitchell. These rulings are explained in more detail below. Also, the request by Wilson’s counsel to consider an oral demurrer is denied.

The Second Amended Motion for Judgment is lengthy (108 paragraphs), repetitious, and inconsistent in parts. It contains six counts alleging various types of tortious conduct, from negligent to intentional acts, against six different defendants.

*536After reading all 108 paragraphs and 29 pages of the Second Amended Motion for Judgment,, the facts alleged are as follows.

Plaintiff was driving a dump truck, which he had rented from United Rentals, Inc. (“United”) eastbound on Route 50 in Loudoun County on the morning of September 8, 2001. At the same time, Wallace and Defendant Chris Mitchell and other workers were using machinery both: in the road and on the shoulder to clear overhead telephone wires of tree limbs and brush.

Plaintiff came over the crest of a blind hill and suddenly came upon the workers. He and another vehicle swerved to avoid hitting the workers. He collided with a tree on the opposite side of Route 50 causing damage to the rented dump truck.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.