Court of Appeals of North Carolina April 5, 2005, COA04-203 (State v. Ayscue)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-04-2005

TIMMONS-GOODSON, Judge.

Charles Lamont Ayscue (“defendant”) appeals his conviction of robbery with a firearm. For the reasons discussed herein, we hold that defendant received a trial free of prejudicial error, but we remand the case for a new sentencing hearing.

The State’s evidence presented at trial tends to show the following: On 13 April 2002, Regina Durham (“Durham”) and Leon Debnam (“Debnam”) were working at Currin’s Mini Mart in Henderson when defendant entered the store and asked Durham for change for a fifty dollar bill. Durham had seen defendant “[n]umerous times” in the store, and the two had “conversations” on more than one occasion. Durham told defendant that she did not keep that much change that late at night, and defendant left the store. Defendant then returned to the store and told Durham, “you know you just made me miss a drug deal.” Durham replied, “well, maybe I just kept you from getting in trouble[,]” and she continued working with other customers.

As Durham was waiting on another customer, defendant “pulled out [a] gun” and demanded that Durham give him money. Durham initially “didn’t pay him any attention,” but after defendant “clicked the gun,” Durham opened the cash register and gave defendant approximately $580.00 in cash. After defendant fled the store, Durham “pushed the panic button” and locked up the store.

Debnam did not notice defendant when he first entered the store, but while Debnam was mopping the floor in front of the cash register he noticed defendant “was real fidgety, and went from one— one end of the register to the other.” Debnam saw what “[ljooked like a nine millimeter” hanging out of defendant’s pants pocket, and he heard defendant say, “give it all here.” Debnam initially believed defendant was talking to a customer in the store, but stated that “when I heard the (makes sound and demonstrates chambering bullet), I looked back, he had the gun pointed at [Durham].

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.