Court of Appeals of Kentucky February 25, 2005, 2004-CA-000984-MR (Donatelli v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-02-2005

OPINION

VANMETER, Judge.

If a criminal defendant is represented by a lawyer who also represents a codefen-dant, that criminal defendant must be informed of the possible conflict of interest by the trial judge and must sign a waiver of the possible conflict.

1

The failure to do so, however, does not necessitate reversal, but requires a defendant to demonstrate an actual conflict of interests. In this case, we hold that the defendant, Christopher Donatelli, has failed to do so, and we therefore affirm.

The facts of this case are relatively straightforward. On November 6, 2003, Donatelli and three other individuals, Gerding, Knox, and Howard, were arrested after hours on the premises of a junkyard. All four were charged with theft by unlawful taking over $300

2

and possession of burglar’s tools.

3

In addition, Do-natelli was charged with persistent felony offender (PFO) first degree.

4

One public defender was appointed to represent Do-natelli, Gerding and Knox. The fourth co-defendant, Howard, retained separate counsel. Prior to Donatelli’s and Gerd-ing’s March 29, 2004 trial, Knox pled guilty to felony theft, and Howard pled guilty to misdemeanor theft. At trial, all four testified consistently that Knox and Howard had removed all the stolen parts from the cars at the junkyard, and that Donatelli and Gerding were just tagging along and did not participate in the theft. The jury convicted Donatelli of both felony theft and possession of burglar’s tools, and he entered a guilty plea to PFO first degree. On May 5, 2004, Donatelli was sentenced to five years for theft by unlawful taking over $300, enhanced to ten years by PFO first degree, and one year for possession of burglar’s tools, with the sentence running concurrent.

5

This appeal follows.

The sole issue advanced by Donatelli on this appeal is that the failure of the trial

*105

court to comply with the requirements of RCr 8.30(1) necessitates reversal of his conviction.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.