United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Arizona August 11, 2005, Bankruptcy No. 2-02-06324-PHX-RJH, Adversary No. 03-00709, Adversary No. 04-1179 (Davis v. Par Wholesale Auto, Inc. (In Re Tucker))

Also known as

United States · · · 11-08-2005

OPINION RE PAR’S RECLAMATION RIGHTS

RANDOLPH J. HAINES, Bankruptcy Judge.

This case presents the issue of whether a reclaiming seller has priority over an unperfected secured creditor. The Court concludes that it does, because an unper-fected secured creditor does not qualify as an “other good faith purchaser.”

Procedural Background

This matter is before the Court on cross-motions for summary judgment filed by Par Wholesale Auto, Inc. (“Par”) and DAVCO Enterprises dba DAVCO Motors & DAVCO Leasing, and C.T. Cook (collectively “DAVCO”). The issue is the ownership of three vehicles sold by Par to Harvest Car Company, which was a dba of the Debtor Edward Tucker (hereafter referred to as “Tucker” or “Harvest”). On June 23, 2005, the Court ruled in favor of Par and against DAVCO as to ownership of the three vehicles, indicating that a subsequent opinion would more fully explain the Court’s analysis and rationale. This is that opinion.

Undisputed Material Facts

The parties are not in total agreement on all the facts, but there are sufficient undisputed material facts upon which the Court is able to enter summary judgment. These are:

Tucker inspected vehicles at Par’s place of business in Texas and purchased the

*295

three vehicles from Par in April 2001.

1

Tucker delivered a check for one of the vehicles and promised to pay the balance for all of the vehicles. The vehicles were transported from Texas to Arizona and delivered to Tucker at Harvest Car Company.

Tucker and DAVCO had a financing agreement

2

whereby DAVCO or C.T. Cook provided floor financing to Tucker to allow Tucker to purchase vehicles and hold them for resale. Per the financing agreement and business dealings between DAV-CO and Tucker, Tucker would sign the certificates of title and deliver them to DAVCO. DAVCO would then hold these “open” titles until Tucker sold the vehicles.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.