United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Oregon December 30, 2005, 16-34738 (Tort Committee v. Roman Catholic Archbishop of Portland in Oregon)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-2005

MEMORANDUM OPINION (TORT CLAIMANTS COMMITTEE’S SECOND RESTATED MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT)

ELIZABETH PERRIS, Bankruptcy Judge.

The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Portland in Oregon, and Successors, a Corporation Sole, dba the Archdiocese of Portland in Oregon (“debtor” or “the Archdiocese”) filed a chapter 11

1

case in 2004. The Archdiocese has taken the position that, although it holds legal title to approximately $98 million in deposits and investment accounts

2

and an extensive amount of real estate, most of that property is held in trust and, thus, is not available to be used to pay the claims of creditors. The Tort Claimants Committee (“TCC”) seeks a determination in this adversary proceeding that the property is property of debtor’s bankruptcy estate and is not subject to any interests of anyone else, and to use the bankruptcy trustee’s powers as a hypothetical bona fide purchaser to avoid any unrecorded interests of third parties in the disputed real property.

The TCC has filed a series of motions for summary judgment, seeking a determination of various aspects of the pending proceeding. It seeks in this Second Restated Motion for Partial Summary Judgment a determination that debtor’s and other defendants’ affirmative defenses of lack of subject matter jurisdiction and religious freedom are without merit. It also seeks a declaration that debtor’s “parishes and schools have no legal existence separate from or independent of Debtor and do not have the capacity to sue or be sued.” Tort Claimants Committee’s Restated Second Motion for Partial Summary Judgment ¶ 4. Responses to this motion were filed by associations or groups representing the interests of Marist High School, Central Catholic High School, Regis High School, and the Committee of Catholic Parishes, Parishioners and Interested Parties (“Parish Committee”).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.