Texas Court of Appeals, 5th District (Dallas) August 11, 2005, 05-03-01837-CV (Dillard Texas Operating Ltd. Partnership v. City of Mesquite)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-08-2005
OPINION
Opinion by
Justice BRIDGES.
Dillard Texas Operating Limited Partnership, L.P. appeals the trial court’s grant of the plea to the jurisdiction in its case against the city of Mesquite, Texas and Allied Waste Systems, Inc. d/b/a Trinity Waste Services, Inc. (“Trinity”). We conclude that Dillard’s had standing to assert its suit seeking a declaratory judgment that Mesquite violated its charter by granting Trinity exclusive rights to haul commercial waste. Thus, the trial court had subject-matter jurisdiction, and the grant of the plea to the jurisdiction was in error.
Facts
Dillard’s owns department stores throughout the Dallas-Fort Worth area, including one at Town East Mall in the city of Mesquite. Since before 1996, Trinity or its predecessor hauled containerized waste for Dillard’s pursuant to a contract between the two commercial parties. In 1996, the city of Mesquite executed a contract with Trinity (the “Agreement”) providing that Trinity would be the exclusive contractor to collect and dispose of containerized waste from businesses -within the city.
Dillard’s eventually became dissatisfied with Trinity’s services and contracted with Express Waste to serve its stores. In September 2002, Express Waste began hauling waste from the Dillard’s store in Mesquite. In January 2003, Mesquite demanded that Dillard’s contract with Trinity, pursuant to an ordinance.
1
The city demanded that Dillard’s contract with Trinity, as the “sole contract holder with rights to all commercial solid waste accounts within the City.” In May 2003, Mesquite passed Ordinance No. 3576 (the “Ordinance”) making it a misdemeanor for any commercial entity to fail to contract with the city or “a company contracting with the city,” for the removal of commercial solid waste. If Dillard’s did not comply, it faced fines of up to $2,000 per occurrence.
Dillard’s sued the city under the Declaratory Judgment Act, challenging the validity of the Agreement. Tex. Crv. PRAC. & Rem.Code Ann. § 37.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit