Court of Chancery of Delaware October 25, 2005, C.A. 20418 (Travelers Insurance Co. v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-10-2005

OPINION AND ORDER

LAMB, Vice Chancellor.

The plaintiff in this case, Travelers Insurance Company, seeks enforcement of an arbitration award made in its favor against the defendant, Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. Nationwide’s pending motion for summary judgment asks the court to deny enforcement of the arbitration panel’s decision, arguing that the panel erred in granting relief to Travelers.

In general, this court refuses to reconsider the decision of an arbitration panel. The strong public policy support for the resolution of disputes through arbitration requires that courts uphold the decisions reached by such panels, unless the party seeking to vacate presents evidence satisfying a few narrow statutory exceptions.

1

This case, however, presents extraordinary facts which render upholding the arbitration panel’s decision contrary to the same public policy which animates the courts’ deference toward arbitration. Simply put, the panel’s decision was plainly wrong, and in opposition to clear statutory mandate. Therefore, for the reasons stated below, the court vacates the arbitration panel’s award pursuant to 10

Del. C.

§ 5714. Any other result would be a gross injustice.

I.

This case arises out of an automobile accident on May 23, 1999, caused by Nationwide’s insured. As a result of that incident, Travelers paid $6,219.59 in PIP/No Fault benefits to its insured, Shelly Evans, who was the operator of the other vehicle involved in the accident. Travelers then sought to recover that sum from Nationwide under the principles of subrogation. Because both companies are signatories to an inter-company arbitration agreement, and have entered into Arbitration Forums, Inc.’s Automobile Subrogation Arbitration Agreement, Travelers’s claims were submitted to arbitration. The arbitration was scheduled for July 11, 2002.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.