California Court of Appeal March 18, 2005, F044492 (City of Modesto v. National Med, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-03-2005

Opinion

LEVY, J.

Appellant, City of Modesto (City), is requesting this court to reverse a judgment denying the City relief on its complaint to recover an alleged business license tax deficiency from respondent, National Med, Inc. (NMI). The trial court ruled that the business license tax ordinance that was operative for the tax years at issue was unconstitutional as applied to NMI because it imposed a tax on business activities occurring outside of the City.

The City has not appealed from the finding that its ordinance was unconstitutional. Rather, the City has amended its business license tax ordinance to provide for apportionment and has adopted apportionment guidelines. The City is requesting this court to remand the matter to the City’s finance director (Finance Director) for a recalculation of NMI’s alleged tax deficiency using the City’s recently adopted apportionment guidelines.

However, in the context of this litigation, the City is not entitled to the remedy it seeks. The underlying complaint was filed to enforce an alleged business tax deficiency that was based on the former unconstitutional ordinance. The City concedes that the Finance Director’s decision finding this additional tax liability is no longer enforceable.

Further, when the City amended its ordinance to include an apportionment provision it made a

substantive

change to this law. Under the former law, taxpayers were not entitled to apportion their gross receipts to reflect out-of-city activities. The ordinance itself specifies that

procedural

changes be applied retroactively.

*522

Moreover, it would not be appropriate for this court to reform the prior law. The tax years at issue are 1996 to 2000, not a modest period of retroactivity. Also, it would be overly burdensome to force NMI to produce up to nine-year-old documentation that it was not previously required to maintain in order to prove “with clarity” its right to apportion gross receipts. Accordingly, the judgment will be affirmed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.