District Court, E.D. Kentucky August 4, 2005, Civ.A. 3:0538JMH (Com. of Kentucky v. China Tob. Anyang Cig. Factory)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-08-2005

*918

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

HOOD, District Judge.

This matter is before the Court on Plaintiffs motion to remand [Record No. 5]. Defendant filed a response to the motion to remand [Record No. 11] to which Plaintiff replied [Record No. 12]. Also before the Court is Defendant’s request for oral argument [Record No. 13] to which Plaintiff responded [Record No. 14]. Having determined that oral argument on this matter is unnecessary and that Plaintiffs motion to remand is now ripe for decision, the Court addresses the merits of said motion at this time.

BACKGROUND

Plaintiff brings this action pursuant to KRS § 131.602(3) to secure injunctions and recover penalties against Defendant, a tobacco product manufacturer, for allegedly failing to comply with the dictates of KRS § 131.602. The statute requires all cigarette manufacturers whose products are sold in the Commonwealth of Kentucky and who do not opt to participate in the “Master Settlement Agreement” to deposit into escrow an amount equal to approximately $4.00 per carton of their cigarettes sold in Kentucky. Plaintiff asserts the instant cause of action, alleging that Defendant has failed to comply with its escrow obligations.

Also pending in this Court is a separate, but related cause of

action'—Tritent Int’l Corp. DWI, LLC v. Commonwealth of Kentucky,

Frankfort Civil Action No. 04-67 (“Tritent”). In such case, the Plaintiffs allege that the Kentucky Master Settlement Agreement statutes (“MSA statutes”) per se violate federal antitrust laws.

DISCUSSION

Initially, it merits mentioning that Defendant removed this cause of action to federal court on

diversity jurisdiction

grounds. However, after Plaintiff argued that the diversity requirements were not met in the motion to remand, Defendant seemingly abandoned “diversity jurisdiction” as its argument for removal. As such, the Court need not address the diversity requirements.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.