Texas Court of Appeals, 3rd District (Austin) February 17, 2005, 03-04-00072-CV (Hartford Casualty Insurance Co. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-02-2005

OPINION

BEA ANN SMITH, Justice.

In this case, we construe finance code section 153.402(c)

1

to determine whether the phrase “may collect from the proceeds of a bond” allows the State

2

to collect from a surety an administrative penalty assessed against the surety’s principal without first providing the surety with notice and opportunity for a hearing. Appellant, Hartford Casualty Insurance Company (Hartford), contends that since the statutory grant of authority regarding administrative penalties found in finance code section 153.402(c) is discretionary, its constitutional right to procedural due process entitles it as a surety to notice and opportunity for a hearing before it can be held liable for an administrative penalty assessed against its principal. The State argues that it would have been useless to provide Hartford with notice and a hearing because Hartford was not a target of the administrative penalty. The district court held that the penalty may be collected from Hartford.

In three issues on appeal, Hartford contends that (1) construing finance code section 153.402(c) to allow the State to collect from a surety, without notice or opportunity for a hearing, the administrative penalty assessed against its principal violates the due process clauses of both the United States and Texas Constitutions; (2) the trial court’s order violates the Texas Administrative Procedure Act (the APA), Administrative Code, and Finance Code; and that (3) the trial court erred by awarding attorney’s fees to the State. Because when possible we interpret a statute in a manner that renders it constitutional, we hold that notice and opportunity for a hearing are implied into finance code section 153.402(c).

FM Props. Operating Co. v. City of Austin,

22 S.W.3d 868, 873 (Tex.2000). Thus, Hartford was denied its right to procedural due process. We reverse and render judgment that the State cannot collect the administrative penalty from Hartford.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.