Court of Appeals of Alaska February 4, 2005, A-8190 (Sergie v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-2005

OPINION

STEWART, Judge.

Evan C. Sergie was convicted of attempted first-degree sexual assault,

1

resisting arrest,

2

interfering with the report of a domestic violence crime,

3

and two counts of fourth-degree assault.

4

On appeal, Sergie claims that neither the attempted sexual assault conviction nor the resisting arrest conviction were supported by sufficient evidence. Ser-gie also argues that the trial court erred in failing to discharge his publicly appointed counsel and by issuing a faulty jury instruction. We conclude that there is ample evidence to support Sergie’s convictions. We also conclude that the .superior court did not err in failing to discharge Sergie’s counsel. Finally, we reject Sergie’s attack on the jury instructions. Therefore, we affirm Sergie’s convictions.

Facts and proceedings

On June 2, 2001, Evan Sergie, his wife, S.S., and their two-year-old son, J.S., traveled to Dillingham to visit A.S., Sergie’s sister. After they arrived at A.S.’s house, Ser-gie went to the liquor store and bought a twelve-pack of beer and a pint of rum. Ser-gie, A.S., and S.S. spent the rest of the evening drinking together.

The next morning, the trio awoke and continued drinking. After a while, Sergie and A.S. argued. Sergie

told

S.S. to get J.S. dressed because he wanted to leave. S.S. prepared J.S., then returned to the living room to tell Sergie that they were ready to go. Sergie told her that everything was all right and that he and his sister had “calmed down,” so S.S. took J.S. back into the bedroom of K.S., another family member.

The trio continued drinking. Soon, A.S. and Sergie resumed arguing. This time,

Sergie

and A.S. pushed and shoved each other. Sergie again told S.S. to get J.S. ready to go. After S.S. had left the room, the argument ended when Sergie pushed A.S. onto the kitchen floor and then threw a chair across the room.

<⅛

Sergie then began arguing with S.S. and pushed her down. Testimony differed on what happened next. A.S.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.