Alaska Supreme Court January 14, 2005, S-10720 (Catalina Yachts v. Pierce)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-2005

combined-opinion

105 P.3d 125 (2005) CATALINA YACHTS, Appellant, v. Jim and Karen PIERCE, Appellees. No. S-10720. Supreme Court of Alaska. January 14, 2005. *126 Eric A. Kueffner, Faulkner Banfield, P.C., Juneau, for Appellant. No appearance by Appellees. Before: FABE, Chief Justice, MATTHEWS, EASTAUGH, and BRYNER, Justices. OPINION FABE, Chief Justice. I. INTRODUCTION Jim and Karen Pierce rejected an offer of judgment made by Catalina Yachts under Alaska Civil Rule 68 in a breach of warranty case. The superior court denied Catalina's later motion for attorney's fees and costs under Alaska Civil Rule 68, holding that the rule did not apply and was preempted by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty-Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act. Because we conclude that Alaska Civil Rule 68 applies, we reverse and remand. II. FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS The underlying facts of this case are set out in Pierce v. Catalina Yachts, a breach of contract and warranty case that came before us in 2000.[1] In summary, Jim and Karen Pierce purchased a new fiberglass sailboat from Catalina Yachts in 1992. Under the warranty, Catalina was responsible for repairing *127 any blisters in the gel coat of the boat that occurred within a year of the boat being placed in the water. The Pierces claimed that their boat's hull developed blisters and that Catalina was responsible for repairing the hull under the warranty. The Pierces were unable to convince Catalina that the gel coat needed to be replaced.[2] They filed suit, bringing claims under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Federal Trade Commission Improvement Act[3] and under Alaska law. Before trial, in January 1996, the Pierces rejected a $38,000 offer of judgment from Catalina, made under Alaska Civil Rule 68.[4] Following trial, the jury awarded the Pierces $12,445 as the reasonable cost of repair.[5] The superior court then calculated the value of the Pierces' judgment using the formula we laid out in Farnsworth v. Steiner.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.