Texas Court of Appeals, 10th District (Waco) June 22, 2005, 10-02-00345-CV (in the Interest of S.A.P., a Child)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-06-2005
IN THE TENTH COURT OF APPEALS No. 10-02-00345-CV In the Interest of S.A.P., a Child, Appellant From the 19th District Court McLennan County, Texas Trial Court No. 2001-1889-1 dissenting Opinion There is much that I could say about the majority’s opinion. I could detail their hostility generally to termination suits. I could discuss the structure and presentation of the evidence in the opinion to push the reader to the result. I could discuss the long effort to ever so subtly shift the standard of review. But it would not matter. You see, what matters here is that they disagree with the jury, the trial judge, and me and have reversed this case on an issue, factual sufficiency, that makes it almost impossible for review because the Texas Supreme Court does not have jurisdiction to review a factual sufficiency determination. I do believe that the standard of review, while carefully quoted and discussed, was not properly applied. But because of the way the opinion is constructed, it is difficult to identify what evidence was disputed, if any, what evidence was undisputed, and upon what factor or element the evidence was applicable or considered by the majority. The primary shortcoming in the opinion is the failure to segregate or identify the disputed evidence that a reasonable fact finder could not have reasonably resolved in favor of the jury’s answer, which evidence is what shifts the jury’s answer from being a finding supported by legally sufficient evidence to an answer not supported by factually sufficient evidence. In the Interest of M.A.H., 2004 Tex. App. LEXIS 6913, *15-22 (Tex. App.—Waco July 28, 2004, no pet.); see In the Interest of C.H., 89 S.W.3d 17 (Tex. 2002). Just dumping all the evidence out in the opinion and then drawing the conclusion desired for the result hardly complies with the express requirement of In the Interest of J.F.C.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit