Texas Court of Appeals, 10th District (Waco) March 9, 2005, 10-03-00375-CV (Texas A&M University System, Texas Engineering Experiment Station and Dr. Mark McLellan v. Dr. Sefa Koseoglu)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-03-2005
IN THE TENTH COURT OF APPEALS No. 10-03-00375-CV Texas A&M University System, Texas Engineering Experiment Station and Dr. Mark McLellan, Appellants v. Dr. Sefa Koseoglu, Appellee From the 361st District Court Brazos County, Texas Trial Court # 03-000679-CV-261 CONCURRING AND DISSENTING Opinion There comes a point in litigation when choices have to be made. There are consequences of making choices. When faced with a plea to the jurisdiction, a party can choose to amend or stand. In Texas, we have extraordinarily liberal pleading rules. And under the applicable standard of review, it’s like horseshoes, you get points for being close; you do not have to land a ringer every time. The ruling we should make should encourage the plaintiff to give it the best shot. The plaintiff should make all the allegations that can be supported to bring the case within a waiver of sovereign immunity. This is especially true once a plea to the jurisdiction has been filed. Thereafter, by the passage of time, it is reasonable to conclude what is in the pleadings is all the plaintiff has to offer the trial court. The trial court should be able to rule on the plea to the jurisdiction based upon what is on file in the way of pleadings and the evidence properly admitted at the hearing that supports a waiver. Based upon that same record, we should be able to review the propriety of the trial court’s ruling. The alternative is what the majority is doing, encouraging the plaintiff to not plead all the information and never amend its pleadings until after it has suffered an adverse ruling. This is not an appeal of a dismissal after an adverse ruling, or no ruling, on special exceptions as was County of Cameron v. Brown, 80 S.W.3d 549 (Tex. 2002). Try as they might to change what Cameron says by rephrasing a quote, by inserting language it did not contain, into a parenthetical used in Cameron to explain a description of the case, see majority op. at pg.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit